AI Therapy Isn’t Real Therapy So Why Are Millions Paying for It?

 The Rise of AI in Mental Health Support

Over the past few years, we’ve seen a surge in AI driven tools meant to support mental health. From chatbots that “listen” to your worries to apps offering CBT-style advice, artificial intelligence is increasingly being positioned as a digital therapist. But there’s a growing concern: many of these tools don’t actually deliver results backed by psychology or clinical studies. So why are people still paying for them?

It turns out, the answer says more about us than it does about the tech.

The Appeal of AI: Why People Turn to Robots Over Humans

1. Convenience Over Everything

Let’s be honest: booking a traditional therapy session can be a hassle. You need to find a licensed therapist, often wait weeks for an appointment, and then pay anywhere from $100 to $200 per hour. In contrast, AI therapy apps are available 24/7, offer instant replies, and often cost much less or even come free with a premium upgrade.

That level of convenience is hard to beat. Even if users know it’s not the same as talking to a real person, the quick, easy access is often enough to keep them engaged.

2. No Judgment, No Stigma

Some people feel nervous or even ashamed to open up to a human therapist. Talking to a machine? That feels safer. AI doesn’t judge. It doesn’t raise an eyebrow or ask follow up questions that make you squirm. For people dealing with sensitive issues especially those new to therapy this “emotional safety net” can feel incredibly valuable, even if the responses aren’t always helpful.

But Do They Work? The Harsh Reality

Despite their popularity, most AI therapists are still incredibly limited. They don’t truly understand emotions. They don’t pick up on context the way a trained therapist does. At best, they offer generic advice pulled from scripts or behavioral therapy models. At worst, they give harmful or misleading responses.

A study by The Lancet found that while AI tools can provide some benefit like encouraging journaling or promoting mindfulness, they rarely meet the standard of care you’d get from a trained mental health professional. Many have no peer-reviewed research behind them at all. And yet, people continue to use them. The Power of the Placebo Effect. Here’s where it gets interesting: just believing that something is helping can actually make you feel better.

This is known as the placebo effect, and it’s surprisingly powerful. If someone thinks their AI app is making a difference even if it's just repeating motivational quotes , they may genuinely experience reduced stress or anxiety, at least in the short term.

The brain is wired to respond to support even if it comes from a chatbot.

The Role of Marketing and Misinformation

Many AI mental health tools are backed by slick marketing campaigns. They promise things like “AI-powered healing” or “therapy at your fingertips.” These phrases sound convincing, especially to people who are desperate for relief and don’t have the time or knowledge to dig into the fine print.

Often, the platforms aren’t completely transparent about what their tools can’t do. And unless you look closely, you might not realize that the app has no clinical oversight or therapeutic training behind it.

Who’s Most at Risk?

Young people, especially teens and college students, are among the biggest users of AI therapy apps. They're tech-savvy, glued to their phones, and often facing serious mental health challenges with little access to affordable help.

For these users, AI apps may feel like a lifeline. But they’re also the group most likely to confuse “talking to a bot” with real therapy—leaving them vulnerable to long-term issues if their deeper problems aren’t properly addressed.

So Should We Just Ditch AI Therapy?

Not necessarily. AI can still play a useful role in mental health just not as a replacement for human therapists.

Here are a few realistic uses for AI in this space:

Mood tracking: AI can log emotional patterns over time.

Reminders for self-care: Apps can prompt users to drink water, meditate, or take a walk.

Crisis detection: Some advanced tools can flag when users might be in danger and offer emergency contacts.

Starting point: AI can serve as a gateway for people who are new to mental health care and might eventually transition to human therapy.

The key is setting the right expectations. AI can support but not replace, real human connection and expertise.

Final Thoughts: What This Trend Says About Us

At the heart of it, people aren't just paying for AI therapy apps they're paying for hope. They're paying for someone to listen. To be there when no one else is. Even if that “someone” is a chatbot with no real understanding of what they’re going through.

It’s a clear signal that mental health support is still inaccessible or intimidating for too many people. Until that changes, people will continue to turn to whatever tools are easiest, even if those tools don't truly "work."

August 17, 2025 Tags : Mental Health

Subscribe by Email

Follow Updates Articles from This Blog via Email